Education
Lifestyle Quixotica

Is Your Collagen Causing Kidney Stones

Collagen vs Creatine?

There really is no Collagen versus Creatine question, however there are differences. 
Creatine is a molecule that produces cellular energy, ATP,  and collagen is a protein crucial for skin and joint health. The fundamental difference lies in their functions and benefits.  Creatine, typically taken in the form of Creatine Monohydrate, has been associated with increasing isotonic lifting capacity (strength), muscle hypertrophy (bulk) and brain health.  Collagen boosts skin elasticity and can expedite the healing process, as does creatine, because creatine synthesizes collagen.  That’s how it works in the proverbial nut shell.

The Big Deal

The big deal is this….. Creatine synthesizes Collagen. If I take Creatine Monohydrate along with Collagen, does the fact Creatine synthesizes Collagen place Collagen on steroids for greater benefits?  Yes, is the simple answer and at the end of the day, I choose Creatine Monohydrate, all day long over everything else, because of the immense benefit creatine provides, beyond anything collagen can do for me.  Let us explore the combined benefits and risks.

Extracellular Matrix Under Skin

Collagen adds structure to the extracellular matrix that lies under your skin.  The trick is to get enough nutrients to support collagen production. 

IT IS MUCH MORE EFFECTIVE TO ENHANCE YOUR BODY’S COLLEGEN PRODUCING PATHWAYS THEN TO MAKE UP FOR LOW LEVELS OF COLLAGEN WITH SUPPLEMENTATION. 

That means what we put in our mouths, to satiate our belly and cells, needs to be up to par and that ain’t goin’ to happen at the MaacoDonold or the cows that want you to eat chickens drive thru, et al.  Get the drift? 

Risk of Collagen Supplements

In 2020 the Organic Consumers Association found that 64% of all store bought processed collagen products tested positive for arsenic.  37% tested positive for lead.  The industry labels these as “Dirty Collagens” and they are pervasive in the collagen supplementation world. You might be surprised as many well-known brands are on the list.  Click on this link to see the list (p10):  Organic Consumers Association. 

Many supplements in the study had No Data (ND) available, so it doesn’t mean they are safe.  It simply means No Data is available. 

Further, according to the Clean Label Project, consumers have an 86% chance of purchasing a collagen product contaminated with heavy metals.  The above study and white paper, published by the Organic Consumers Association also reported levels of Cadmium (CD), Mercury and Lead in the Collagen Supplements tested.  For the industrious, take a look for yourself. 

Serious Health Risks of Collagen Supplementation

Other issues from too much collagen supplementation versus supporting your bodies’ natural production include:

  1. Development of kidney stones and renal (kidney) failure: Hydroxyproline, a major collagen amino acid in supplements is normally disposed of through the kidneys as oxalate: a kidney stone trigger.
    Specifically, as cited in Kidney International, Author Manuscript (PubMed 2006), “The most common form of kidney stone is composed of calcium oxalate. Oxalate excreted in urine is derived in approximately equal parts from the diet and endogenous synthesis.  An increased endogenous production of oxalate in the primary hyperoxalurias (PHs) not only dramatically increases stone formation, but can in some individuals lead to tissue deposition of calcium oxalate and renal failure.”
  2. Liver Fibrosis:  According to the Journal of Clinical Investigation, “Liver fibrosis is the excessive accumulation of extracellular matrix proteins including collagen that occurs in most types of chronic liver diseases. Advanced liver fibrosis results in cirrhosis, liver failure, and portal hypertension and often requires liver transplantation.”   Other research indicates Liver fibrosis may come from the excessive accumulation of type I collagen in your liver tissue. Collagen supplementation, which commonly includes type 1 collagen intake, may worsen your liver’s condition as unmanaged liver fibrosis gradually leads to liver cancer and/or cirrhosis.
  3. Heart Issues:  Collagen can cause hypercalcemia. Hypercalcemia is an overaccumulation of calcium. Excessive calcium from collagen supplements may  result in an abnormal heart rhythm.
  4. Digestive/Stomach Issues:  You can also experience digestive problems as a side effect of taking collagen. Some of the symptoms you may experience include diarrhea, constipation, and heartburn, alongside feeling bloated and having a reduced appetite.  Remember, your ability to poop and eliminate properly, on a daily basis, is critical in eliminating toxins and your health.  If you aren’t eliminating properly or have diarrhea, your colon is a ticking time bomb to disease.

Bottom Line

Are the risks of collagen supplementation a bad thing? Not always, however thoroughly vet out what you are taking and the sources of collagen supplementation. I choose making my own collagen broth from scratch, not any store bought, unknown source of collagen.  Here is a link to our homemade bone broth recipe full of healthy collagen:  Quixotica Bone Broth Recipe.

A 2018 study on store bought non-hydrolyzed bone broth, concluded, “It is unlikely that processed store bought bone broth collagen can provide a consistently reliable source of amino acids”.  Purchase Hydrolyzed Collagen if you choose to use commercial brands. How much money have we wasted on ineffective collagen products that provide gastric distress and potentially expose us to toxins and other health issues?

This is the reason society, and myself, have shunned most collagen supplements, especially the cheap ineffective ones from chicken bones.  Cheap to make but very profitable for the manufacturers.  The stark reality of industrialized nutritional supplementation. 

The Solution

Enter Creatine Monohydrate that I have utilized and prescribed for over 30 years. Creatine is one of the most studied and effective ergogenic aids for athletes and all of us in our activities of daily living.  Creatine exerts anerobic energy capacity, decreasing protein breakdown, leading to increased muscle mass and physical performance as well as improved skin health. 

Creatine has been used effectively as a nutritional strategy to maintain functional and mental capacity and, as we age, reduce the risk to chronic disease and dementia. I utilized it with dementia and Alzheimer’s patients with remarkable outcomes.

The International Society of Sports Nutrition (2007), concluded creatine is “The most effective ergogenic nutritional supplement currently available to athletes in terms of increasing high-intensity exercise capacity and lean body mass during training”.  Creatine supplementation has been shown to:

  • Manage blood lipid levels 
  • Reduce accumulation of fat on the liver 
  • Decrease homocysteine, reducing risk of heart disease 
  • Serve as an antioxidant 
  • Enhance glycemic control (blood sugar levels) 
  • Reduce progress of some cancers 
  • Minimize bone loss
  • Improve functional capacity in osteoarthritic and fibromyalgia
  • Improve cognitive function in older populations. 

Based on current evidence, creatine supplementation can increase cellular energy availability & enhance general health, fitness & well-being.

What About Naysayers?

Enter the creatine naysayers that claim creatine monohydrate damages the kidneys and increases water retention.  I was taught that as well, however none of it is accurate. Kidney damage reported in body builders, notoriously dehydrated, especially before and during posing, is the issue.  Dehydration, to include most of society, will cause kidney damage.  With regard to increased water retention, muscle is 80% water. What exactly is the debate?

Brose and colleagues (PubMed 2003) were the first to report creatine promoted greater gains in muscle mass and isometric muscle strength.  Chrush reported geriatrics that supplemented with Creatine experienced greater gains in lean tissue mass, over-all body strength and endurance.  

Chilibeck and associates (PubMed 2015) found creatine supplementation increased strength and bone density in postmenopausal women.  Watanabe and associates (PubMed 2002) found creatine increased oxygen utilization in the brain and reduced mental fatigue.  Rae, et al (PubMed 20023) found working memory and processing speed increased with creatine supplementation. Creatine promoted significant reduction in A1C in diabetics.

Further Benefits of Creatine

Maternal creatine supplementation was reported to improve neonatal survival and organ function following birth asphyxia as well as neural development. (BMC Pregnancy & Childbirth, PubMed 2014)

Researchers concluded creatine is an important metabolic regulator controlling anti-tumor T-cell immunity (Journal of Experimental Medicine, 2019). 

Creatine has been utilized in intrauterine insemination to increase viability of sperm and success of fertility treatments. (Human Reproduction, 2019). Creatine has been reported to affect energy status in the dermis(skin) and is an anti-oxidant.  That means creatine facilitates reduction in skin wrinkles and sagging.  Peirano found topically applied creatine rapidly penetrates the dermis (skin), stimulates collagen synthesis and influences gene expression and protein. (Controlled Clinical Trial, 2011). The same study showed a topical creatine formulation significantly reduced the sagging cheek intensity in the jowl area, crow’s feet wrinkle and bulging under the eyes.

What I Do and How I Do It

I choose Creatine Monohydrate for all-encompassing benefits, including collagen synthesis.  I cycle on and off Creatine. Typically, 4 weeks on and 2 weeks off. Why? To shock the body & to achieve enhanced long term outcomes.

Not daily, as dosing depends on activity level.  I do not utilize store bought collagen products due to the gastric distress and unknown quality of the collagen source.  I do not recommend collagen supplementation daily.  I recommend squaring away your nutrition so you can synthesize collagen naturally.  I utilize MSM, Sulphur, 2-3 days per week for joint health or our Joint Relief Formula (provides joint relief).  I do not recommend Chondroitin Sulfate or Glucosamine supplements as I have found them to be clinically ineffective with patients. 

For a topical cream, I recommend a mixture of creatine monohydrate & minerals from shea butter and/or coconut oil, as research shows this combination improves sun damage, reducing wrinkles and sag. 

I utilize both collagen and creatine.  I make my own collagen from clean organic sources (homemade bone broth), not over-priced, store bought, highly processed products, often from diseased CAFO chickens.  If I had only one choice, it would be Creatine over collagen. Ultimately, you need to experience what works best for you, weigh the risks if you aren’t getting collagen from food or supporting your body to make it.  Like our brother, Rich Piana eloquently said, “Don’t take my word for it, experience it for yourself and make the decision that is best for you”. 

Creatine Monohydrate enhances Mitochondrial respiration, which are the powerhouses of your cells.  Guess where the Holy Grail of Energy, ATP,  is synthesized from?  The Mitochondria.  Collagen cannot provide that benefit.   

To make it easy, we custom formulated Mito Greens, a 2 in1 formula with dark leafy greens from the sea & land + Creatine & D-ribose (supports mitochondria rejuvenation and collagen production).  See link below for Dr. Antonacci’s video on Benefits of Mito Greens with creatine. 

Make Lifestyle Quixotica Part of Your Daily Routine

Have questions about adding formulas to your daily routine? We’re here to support your wellness journey.