Education
Lifestyle Quixotica

Body Fat and BMI Confusion

Body Fat & BMI Revisited

I am re-introducing the following essay written in 2016, on the day of the American Medical Association’s statement regarding the validity of the BMI.  Their recent June 14th, 2023 article; validated every point I made in my 2016 essay and what I have been teaching for decades.

A great deal of confusion and misunderstanding surrounds the BMI or Body Mass Index.  Many live and die by its formula and use it in determining employment, insurance coverage, etc.  And many express the notion that BMI is quite invalid and ineffective in determining anything relative to health, certainly obesity. 

What exactly is the Body Mass Index formula and how is it calculated?  BMI is a 200-year-old formula that takes the ratio between your height and weight, squares it and renders a numerical result that many reviewers will use to determine a level of health. The numerical results are reported in percentages as follows:

  • 18-24%  Normal (whatever normal means) 
  • 25-29% Overweight
  • 30-39% Obese
  • Greater than 40% Morbidly Obese

BMI = Bogus Metabolic Idea

Regrettably, the BMI comes nowhere near to offering anyone any semblance of an idea of a measure of health and/or obesity.  So, let’s explore the idea of BMI and why it should never be used as any type of marker of health.  In fact, we should refer to BMI as Bogus Metabolic Idea, whose time never should have been and now should be gone and buried with dial up internet.

#1 & Most Important: BMI Does Not Consider Body Types

The 3 Body types are Mesomorph, Ectomorph and Endomorph.  The significance of the failure for BMI to address this is critical and very unfortunate because many folks have been unduly disqualified from jobs, etc., due to a high BMI. 

For example, someone who is an athletic combination of “Meso” and “Ecto”, is fit, trains a lot at 6’, 200#’s with 15% body fat and healthy, is considered obese, unhealthy and at risk for heart disease, diabetes and cancer and a menace to society.  That was me when I was disqualified from a fire department candidate position, as the county doctor deemed me obese and unfit after I smoked everyone during the physical agility course.  Although many could make a solid argument regarding the ‘menace to society’ part, huh?

Mesomorphs usually have an easier time losing weight, their metabolism is efficient, and gaining muscle is quite easy as they responds easily to exercise. They are more muscular with larger bone structures. Arnold is a perfect illustration of a classic pure Mesomorph.  Was Arnold obese at 6’2” and 275 pounds when he competed and won 7 Mr. Olympia’s?  By BMI standards, he was grossly obese with 12% body fat. Get the picture?

Ectomorphs usually have difficulty gaining weight and muscle which is why they are typically called ‘hard gainers’. Their metabolism is fast and efficient and they are characterized by a slender lean frame and smaller bone structure than a mesomorph. 

Endomorphs usually have a slow metabolic rate, which is why weight gain is very easy and losing weight can be challenging with bouts of fatigue and malaise.  This would be characterized by having more of a pear-shaped body; however, the endomorph can gain muscle easier than the ectomorph.

Can You Be More than One Body Type?

Is it possible you could be a combination of two or more of the body types?  It is not only possible; it is more likely probable. It means YES with an exclamation point!  Very rarely will you see a pure, 1-type body type.  The majority of the time you will see a combination of body types.

If you have ever seen a Tongan or Samoan person you are looking at a classic combination of Mesomorph and Endomorph, women and men that are 5’9” upwards to well over 6’ and weighing upwards of 300#’s plus, often times.  That body type is not going to ever be Twiggy, ever. These are genetically large individuals from childhood and that is normal for them.  To attempt to tell these body types they need to be a certain weight, especially when all systems are a go and-in-the-pink and they are healthy is incomprehensible.  Which brings us to people that do a great deal of damage to young girls and boys with this notion of body/weight ratios as health markers.

Anorexia and Bulimia Increased

What doctors, PE teachers, school nurses and health professors created was an immense amount of self-esteem and self-image issues among young girls as they decimated self-worth while spiking levels of anorexia and bulimia. In fact, a 2022 study published in the Clinical Journal of Medicine found that, “Taken together, our data support the lack of validity of current BMI specifiers in anorexia nervosa (AN), even in the acute setting.”

BTW, just because you are overweight or even obese, does that mean you are not qualified to be employed?  Well, that is also what the aforementioned created.  They deemed you unemployable with the BMI rhetoric and employers are continuing the same nonsensical archaic approach.  Let us take that ignorance a step further.  Just because you are overweight does it mean you are less than and not lovable?  Critically think about how much damage they have done to young girls, boys and society.

Here is some good news coming from an 8th grade, erudite young girl from Indiana that challenges the BMI notion.  In 2016,  as published in Vox Science, a school in Indiana asked its students to explain the importance of BMI.  Little did they know this young girl was lurking in the wings waiting to pounce on this issue as outdated, flawed and used for more health standards than it was ever intended for.  She wrote a letter to the district explaining that because she is a softball player, her body is muscular and bigger than many of her classmates.  In essence, she was explaining that she was being compared to a gymnast or dancer, which is what we do in our society and that is wrong.

“Cubby Hole” Healthcare Model

We cubby hole everyone into the same slot even though we are very different in makeup from one another.  And that is the problem in our failed health care system in the US. Everyone is treated the same by the Allopathic community, which is incomprehensible and egregious.  Simply, this is one of the reasons, other than crisis trauma care and surgery, that accounts for only 20%, their system continues to crash and fail in providing health care. 

According to the American Medical Association, nearly 63% of physicians are reporting signs of burnout. Further, per the AMA’s president, Jesse M Ehrenfeld, MD, MPH, over 60% of all MD’s are burned out because they no longer are allowed a patient doctor relationship as protocols are now dictated by the big box they work for, the administrators and insurance companies. Specifically, according to a CBS News June 15, 2023 report, Ehrenfeld stated, “Well, in at least six states, now, if I practice evidence-based care, I can go to jail,” Ehrenfeld said. “It’s frightening. When a patient shows up in my office, if I do the right thing from a scientific, from an ethical perspective, to know that that care is no longer legal, criminalized and could wind me in prison.”

Sound familiar?  The AMA’s president is calling this a national public health crisis. Allopathic MD’s practicing with handcuffs. And the level of care has gone south thanks to the Affordable Care Act that handed over our health to the pharmaceutical and insurance industries.

The BMI is used as a shortcut that does not offer a clear picture of an individual’s health and is regrettably used by many doctors, health and physical education teachers, many of which are truly obese themselves and school health personnel that are uninformed and academically not current.  

Even the Centers for Disease Control, CDC, recommends against using the BMI as a marker for overall health.  Not that the CDC is a credible organization any longer,  however, every once and a while they get it right as long as it meets with their agenda of pretending to protect us.

A study published in the International Journal of Obesity found that one half, 50% of those individuals classified as overweight and 1/3 of all those classified as obese had perfectly healthy blood pressure, cholesterol and insulin levels.  Now what?

An appropriate weight for each body type should be based on eating clean, unadulterated foods, hydrating properly, cleansing frequently, exercising regularly and supplementing with a good probiotic (like FloraBiotica) and a good digestive enzyme, like Digest Synergy.  A plant based digestive enzyme is critical in helping you properly breakdown food, absorb nutrients and discard what you don’t need.  Sadly, it is often overlooked. Without proper evacuation of wastes, fecal matter accumulates in the colon, becomes impacted and may contribute to a bloated and uncomfortable belly.  Further, this putrefied fecal matter often leaks into your blood stream, contributing to illness. Click on the radio button below to hear what Dr. Tony has to say (only 1-1/2 minutes).

Getting Back to Dispelling the BMI Myths….

#2 The 19 century Belgian mathematician Lambert Adolphe Jacques Quetelet, who dreamed up the BMI, even said that it should never be used as a health marker. It is an archaic and failed method to measure obesity in society.  This sounds like Albert Sabin, MD, the inventor of the Sabin Polio vaccine saying the mass vaccination program is a miserable failure but we are still doing both.

#3 Playing off the body types, the BMI makes absolutely no allowance for proportions of bone, muscle and fat.  Thus, athletes and fit, health-conscious folk who train consistently, especially with resistance are often deemed over weight and obese.

#4  It makes no physiological academic sense to square a person’s height.  It is as NPR said, “mathematical snake oil with no scientific authority”.

#5 The insurance companies are using BMI to determine premiums….well, that says it all, doesn’t it?  

#6 Considering the United States of America is documented as the most obese country on earth by leaps and bounds, it should be quite embarrassing for the aforementioned so-called experts and the US to promote the Bogus Metabolic Idea. 

#7 Although, the BMI pushers claim it to be an indirect indicator of body fat %, it is not, never has been and was never intended for that purpose. You must test for body fat %, which is a more valid indicator of health, by using other means such as hydrostatic weighing and bio-impedance devices (below right).  Fat caliper testing (below left) was shown to be difficult as it sorely depends on the skill of the tester.  We did a study in college comparing the testing with calipers among those of us in the exercise of physiology laboratory and found differences as high as +5% and beyond.  Not an accurate way of determining body fat %. The calipers should be retired just like the Bogus Metabolic Idea.

Embrace and Love Your Body, Take Care of You

The majority of nationally certified strength and conditioning coach’s, like myself, find the ‘Bogus Metabolic Idea’, laughable. If your doctor, health professor or, worse, a personal trainer with a 12-hour certificate uses BMI as a health marker with you, find a new doctor, professor and trainer.

Love your body and yourself as you are.  You are beyond compare, whole and complete and simply need to see that, believe and know it.  There is nothing more you need to do but simply enjoy yourself through this journey, feed your cells with real alive food, move and honor your body that you have been blessed with.  Never, ever allow the ignorant and uninformed to tame your spirit.  Express yourself with vigor in compassion and empathy.  There is nothing noble in dimming your light to appease ignorance.

N.E.R.F. to Support Your Body, Basic Tips & Specials

The Taking Care of Yourself and supporting your Body, Your Temple, is encapsulated in our acronym N.E.R.F.

N = Nutrition is the Medicine

E = Exercise is the Catalyst

R = Rest is When the Body Heals, Recovers and Rejuvenates

F = Faith is the Anchor, the foundation that supports everything else

This means you must:

  1. Eat to Feed Your Cells, Not Your Belly
  2. Exercise and Move Your Body
  3. Put the Good Stuff In & Get the Bad Stuff Out – Eat clean, unprocessed foods and use clean, food based supplements to support your body and give it the fuel source it needs.  Also, Fast & Cleanse periodically to purge any unwanted toxins that weigh you down and make you sick.

Make Lifestyle Quixotica Part of Your Daily Routine

Have questions about adding formulas to your daily routine? We’re here to support your wellness journey.